My take on online drug retail for Indian Express

9 Jun

A couple of weeks ago, I met senior executives from Bengaluru start-up PM Health & Life Care. The company is getting ready to fire off an online marketplace for prescription drugs that connects chemists to consumers. I was surprised with the timing; that they would choose to reach out when just a little before, the Maharashtra Food & Drugs Administration cracked down on Snapdeal for allowing vendors to sell drugs online. More on why they felt emboldened, later.

Intermediaries for online drug retail will have to shoulder a far greater responsibility for what passes through their channels than they would say, for clothes or shoes. Read why in this column that I wrote for Indian Express published today. And yet, given the far from well-governed nature of drug retail in the country – where drugs are routinely sold without prescription and laws flouted – the intermediary can only be as good as its partner on the ground.

P M Health plans to throw technology at the problem. It believes that by minimising human discretion from click to delivery, it can ensure that no drug is sold without a valid doctor’s prescription and that only legitimate orders are fulfilled. For instance, unless a scanned copy of the doctor’s prescription is uploaded on the site and is verified by a “command centre” manned by pharmacists, the system will not let it be fulfilled. The chemist rep making the delivery will be “trained” to hand over the drugs only after he or she has hologrammed the original prescription (after checking it against the uploaded version) and sent a scanned copy of this original to the centre. It claims to have tied up with only those chemists that employ full-time pharmacists and assured me it would drop any chemist found flouting the rules.

As I have observed in the column, its proposed system of surprise checks of vendors, training and audits put me in mind of a company outsourcing its core activity rather than merely acting as a conduit. That is a tall order. Progress (or scale-up) will be gradual and compliance will be a continuous challenge.

And then there is the law.  It shows no sign of keeping pace; there is no clear legal pathway for online drug retail. So, skirmishes between intermediaries and regulators cannot be ruled out. True, with chemists routinely delivering orders placed over the phone in cities, the real world is way ahead of the law. But that is no reason for regulators to wink at such behaviour from corporates as the Snapdeal episode shows. Too much of that and investors will get spooked so fund-raising will be a challenge.

This blog is in favour of convenience. And if done correctly, online retail – once proven in the cities – could become an efficient method of reaching drugs to consumers beyond cities and towns where access continues to be a problem. But if done badly, it might compound long-standing issues of self-medication and spurious drugs. That is a situation that no amount of convenience can justify.

Advertisements

6 Responses to “My take on online drug retail for Indian Express”

  1. vince June 9, 2015 at 7:36 pm #

    If done properly (e.g., chemists employed in each state to verify prescription since the practice of pharmacy is a state licensed subject), online availability can increase access to rural areas as well as provide reliable retail data for pharma companies and potentially allow insurance tools such as PBMs to offer coverage for out-patient drugs. Of course, we can probably anticipate some push back ultimately by the wholesalers that could eventually be cut out of the equation in highly dense markets

    Like

  2. Anup Soans (@anupsoans) June 9, 2015 at 7:43 pm #

    Timely and thoughtful post.

    Online pharmacy is not a task for companies that ‘throw technology’ at everything – hologram; really?

    Done properly, this is the next big opportunity for those who understand Indian Healthcare at the ground level and are willing to deploy technology as an enabler not a panacea.

    Like

    • Varadharajan K (@VaradhKrish) June 10, 2015 at 10:49 am #

      I agree. Enabler and not a panacea. Will depend on #startups or those who invest understanding healthcare that way and understand long-term vision and business cycles. Fundamentally they have to understand #healthcare is not just a business and cannot be.

      Like

  3. Varadharajan K (@VaradhKrish) June 10, 2015 at 10:45 am #

    Good article. Timely too. Kudos! If done properly will involve: Sticking to the protocols within the legal system(as on date) and not diluting it for the sake of business or in the number-crunching game or for biz growth reasons alone. As in one of the comments made here, “retail data for pharma” is a huge goldmine and it should not be touched(read sold for biz reasons) to #pharma companies at any cost. If done, it shall invite enough legal complications which will defeat the entire original noble objective of throwing technology(atleast sounds noble) between chemists and consumers and the sainthood of customer-centric approach. It will also invite undue influence from other stakeholders to an extent you will loose control of the biz. There are many more landmines but if the businesses stick to the moral ground and original business objectives and not consider this or equate this with other retail opportunity and draw parallels to justify things, it should work like wonder. my quick 0.02

    Like

  4. Varadharajan K (@VaradhKrish) June 10, 2015 at 11:01 am #

    This article incidentally goes well with my tweet sometime back https://twitter.com/VaradhKrish/status/608232358806999040 The key here is building trust. Using that data for Pharma or other business-end motives will destroy that trust right in the bud is my pov.

    Like

  5. Find Doctors Online June 18, 2015 at 9:58 pm #

    Buying medicine online would be very difficult for a simple online users…

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: