Stop tinkering with FDI norms : my column in the Indian Express

Today’s edition of the Indian Express has an edit piece that I have authored on why the government should stop repeatedly tinkering with India’s foreign direct investment (FDI) policy for pharmaceuticals.

In this piece I have argued that there is no connection between the availability of essential medicines and the FDI policy and that this repeated hullabaloo around foreign investment is taking away the focus from those factors that do, in fact, have an impact on essential medicines. Not to mention the blatant double standards that it displays towards foreign-owned companies. You can read the column here

In the past, this blog has repeatedly argued that FDI policy is not the tool to tackle drug availability and affordability issues. See here and here.

In a general way, it never fails to surprise me how easy it is in the corridors of government to lose sight of real issues and focus instead on bogeymen. I wish for instance that at least as much umbrage directed at the foreigners was reserved for increasingly drug-resistant bugs that are a more significant and immediate threat to the health of scores of Indians. I wish that some of the energy that is spent on devising ways and means to clip the wings of foreign companies, were invested instead in designing meaningful public-private partnerships to discover new drugs such as antibiotics and then making sure they are executed.

But no, it’s much easier to say ‘Boo’ to the bogeyman, isn’t it?

In the meantime, some of those Indian businessmen who sold out are doing very interesting things in healthcare itself though it may not be in drug manufacturing. One example is Anand Burman who sold Dabur Pharma, a maker of generic cancer drugs, to Germany’s Fresenius Kabi in 2008. He helped raise a private equity fund for healthcare investments, also investing his own funds in it, in 2010. The Asian Healthcare Fund’s portfolio includes a chain of neighbourhood clinics that provide primary care in cities.

His family has also partnered with foreign companies to foray into training of healthcare professionals, and to provide home-based medical care.  These are all felt needs in Indian healthcare.

Am I the only one who thinks that the Burmans are unlikely to have waded this far into healthcare if they were busy managing a generic drugs business simply because the government thought they should?







One thought on “Stop tinkering with FDI norms : my column in the Indian Express

  1. Good insights. FDI norms have the unintended consequence of driving Indian businesses to invest outside of the country. FDI restrictions on drug manufacturers are unfathomable. There are over 10,000 licensed drug manufacturers in India- too many for the government to even properly inspect. One drug alone, generic Lipitor has over 600 version being manufacture in India. India desperately needs some consolidation and rationalization of its drug manufacturing chaos. Gauri is right! FDI is being used by politicians as a bogeyman that want to distract attention from the lack of progress on building health care capacity and implementing workable solutions to improving access to medicines for poor and vulnerable population..


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s